If you search for signs you need an executive coach, most of what comes up reads like an org chart. You just got promoted. Your team doubled. You got tough feedback in your review. Those are real reasons, and plenty of people start coaching at exactly those moments.
Most of the executives who reach out to me aren't in the middle of a promotion, though. Their reasons are harder to put on a list. They're doing well by every outside measure, something still feels off, and they can't tell whether it's big enough to justify getting help.
So these are the signs I actually see in people right before they decide to work with a coach. They're internal, which makes them easy to talk yourself out of.
How do I know if I need an executive coach?
If the same patterns keep showing up no matter how much you understand them, if you're functioning well but paying for it in ways nobody sees, or if you've been waiting for a better time to deal with something for longer than you'd like to admit, it's worth a conversation.
Executive coaching tends to help most when the problem isn't information. You already know a lot. You've probably read the books. What's missing is the bridge between knowing what you'd like to do differently and actually doing it when the pressure is on.
The rest of this post goes through those signs one at a time.
Why does the same problem keep showing up no matter what changes?
New role, new team, sometimes a whole new company, and somehow you end up in the same spot. The same kind of person gets under your skin. You take on too much again. You avoid the same type of conversation until it becomes a bigger conversation.
When a problem follows you from job to job, it usually isn't about the job. It's a pattern, and patterns are hard to see from the inside because they feel like just how things are.
This is one of the clearest signs I know of. Insight isn't converting into change, and you've already tried the obvious fixes on your own.
When a problem follows you from job to job, it usually isn't about the job.
Read more: What Actually Happens in 1:1 Executive Coaching?
Is dreading Sunday nights a sign something needs to change?
Friday you finish exhausted. Saturday you decompress. Then somewhere around 4pm on Sunday it starts, the dread and the mood shift that nobody in your house is allowed to comment on.
The Sunday Scaries have become so normal you can buy a t-shirt about them. I'd push back on that. Weekly dread is information. It often means you're tolerating something at work, a dynamic, a manager, a culture, a role that no longer fits, and you've gotten so good at rationalizing it that you only feel it in unguarded moments.
When I was at Target, my version showed up on the last day of every vacation. Every single time, a wave of dread as the corporate grind came back into view. I got very good at calling it "just how the end of a vacation feels" instead of looking at what it was telling me.
If you're an entrepreneur, yours might look different. It's the one task you'll do anything to avoid, up to and including deep cleaning your entire kitchen. Sometimes that's just a task you don't enjoy. Sometimes it's pointing at a fear or a story the task stirs up.
What if you've been waiting for things to settle down?
"Once the reorg is done." "After the kids go back to school." "When the new fiscal year starts."
Waiting for the right moment makes sense on the surface. But when I look closely with clients, the waiting usually isn't about timing. There's a tiredness underneath that hasn't been dealt with, and starting something new while running on low feels like too much. So you give yourself a reasonable reason to hold off, the season changes, things get busier, and that same exhaustion comes along into the next quarter.
A new planner won't touch it, and neither will the fresh start you've been promising yourself since January. If you've been saying "once things settle down" for more than a season, that's worth paying attention to on its own.
Read more: The Cost of Waiting to Get Coaching (It's Not Just Time)
Why can you coach everyone else but not yourself?
You're the one people come to. Your team, your peers, your friends. You give good advice, you see what other people are missing, and you can usually help them figure out what to do next.
Then you try to do the same for yourself and it doesn't work. You're too close to it, and you already know all the arguments on every side, so you go in circles.
There's also a loneliness that comes with being the person everyone leans on. Senior leaders often don't have anyone to think out loud with who doesn't have a stake in the outcome. Your boss has an opinion. Your team needs you steady. Your partner has heard it already. Having one place where you don't have to manage anyone's reaction changes how clearly you can think.
Having one place where you don't have to manage anyone's reaction changes how clearly you can think.
What are the benefits of executive coaching?
The benefits people expect are usually tactical: better delegation, clearer communication, more strategic thinking. Those do happen.
What clients tend to talk about months later is different. They understand how they react under pressure and can catch it earlier. Decisions stop taking so much out of them. They stop carrying things that were never theirs to carry. Work still gets hard, but it takes less out of them, and they have more left for the rest of their life.
Good executive coaching isn't someone telling you what to do. It's someone helping you see the pattern that's been making the obvious answer so hard to act on.
Read more: Why Stress Management Isn't Working for You
When is executive coaching not the right fit?
I'd rather say this plainly. If you're looking for someone to hand you a plan and hold you accountable to it, a consultant or a mentor may suit you better. If what you're dealing with is depression, anxiety that's affecting your daily functioning, or something rooted in trauma, a licensed therapist is the right first step, and coaching can come alongside or after.
A good coach will tell you when something is outside their lane.
Read more: Life Coaching vs. Therapy: What's the Difference and Do You Need Both?
Frequently Asked Questions
-
When the same challenges keep repeating despite your best efforts, when you're performing well but it's costing you more than it should, or when you've been putting off dealing with something for a long time. A promotion or transition is one reason, but not the only one.
-
No. Many clients come to coaching in the middle of a role they plan to stay in. They want to feel different in it, lead differently, or stop repeating a pattern.
-
Clearer self-awareness under pressure, easier decision-making, better boundaries, and lasting behavior change, as opposed to short-term motivation.
-
A typical engagement is around 12 sessions over several months. That gives enough time to understand your patterns and practice changing them in real situations.
If you recognized yourself in more than one of these, that's usually enough reason to at least have a conversation. You don't need to wait for a promotion or a crisis to get support.
Wondering if coaching makes sense for you right now?
A consult call is a relaxed conversation about what's going on and whether working together could help. It's a conversation, not a pitch. Book a consult call here.
Not ready yet? Join the newsletter and keep thinking about it with me each week.